Red Dead Redemption 2 PC vs PS5 (Pro)

As someone who owns both a high-end gaming PC and a PS5 Pro, I find it both frustrating and unnecessary that there isn’t a modern console update to address the graphical and performance issues in Red Dead Redemption 2. The PS5 runs the game the same as the PS4 Pro: no visual or performance upgrades.

Red Dead Redemption 2 PS4 Version on PS5 (Pro)

Red Dead Redemption 2 is locked at a horrendous 30 fps. For a long time, console gamers were comfortable with games running at 30 fps, but that changed with the PS5 and Xbox Series X. PC gamers had long struggled with limited performance, as games didn’t feel fluid; instead, they were constantly constrained. But, as 60+ fps has become standard, dropping down to 30 fps can be painful. But RDR2’s problems aren’t limited to the frame rate; it’s also limited to 1080p, and even that doesn’t feel native. It looks okay, but not great, and not how it should, especially compared to PC.

I should note that Red Dead Redemption 2 on the PS5 isn’t unplayable, far from it, but it’s lacking the polish that makes the world feel real. Based on the various PC settings, there’s no reason to suggest that the PS5 would struggle to perform at 60 fps on the equivalent of medium or high settings.

Red Dead Redemption 2 PC

I’ve owned Red Dead Redemption 2 on PC since its release, and every time I try playing the console versions, I’m disappointed and end up returning to PC. PC games always benefit from the freedom of open resolutions and, for the most part, unlocked frame rates, although some games do restrict them, but no lower than 60 fps. Fortunately, I’m able to play Red Dead Redemption 2 on maximum settings on an ultrawide 1440p 180hz monitor at 120+ fps. So, not only is the resolution at 3440 x 1400 higher than the 1920 x 1080 console lock, but the graphics settings are significantly higher, and the performance outperforms consoles by an embarrassing margin. All of these graphical performance upgrades amount to an immersive, cinematic, almost life-like experience. What console gamers dream of, PC gamers have had since launch, and that’s the same for most games.

Walking around the town of Valentine at night feels like being in a movie; it’s incredible. The lighting and the darkness make the area feel noticeably different to daytime, providing a contrasting experience from a welcoming town to the feeling of sinister undertones. With dynamic weather, the world comes to life. With high-resolution detail, even blades of grass and the animals rustling within it are clear and easy to notice. Everything feels alive. Red Dead Redemption 2 is a masterpiece, and the PC version offers an opportunity to experience it in all its glory.

Red Dead Redemption 2 PC Screenshots
(Ryzen 9600x, 32GB RAM, RX 9070XT 16GB)

Conclusion

It’s a travesty that Rockstar hasn’t provided a next-generation update for Red Dead Redemption 2 on PS5 or Xbox Series X. With the PC version running the game perfectly well and being so customizable, one would assume it wouldn’t take much work to provide an official upgrade for the latest consoles. Whilst I can play RDR2 on PC, as it’s a cinematic game, I would like to enjoy it on the bigger screen in the living room on my PS5 Pro console, and that shouldn’t feel like a pipe dream! I’ve tried playing the only version available, the PS4 release, and whilst it plays okay, it’s hardly remarkable. To enjoy it, one has to accept its limitations and be okay knowing it could be significantly better.

If I didn’t have access to a PC, then I would likely make peace playing the PS4 version, but that doesn’t make it acceptable. I even tested Red Dead Redemption 2 on the Legion Go S Z1 Extreme (32GB RAM) Steam OS PC Handheld, and, as it has a much smaller screen than a monitor or TV, it looked better than the PlayStation version and ran at 40-50+ fps. Even a handheld device runs the game better than a console! Fortunately, saves transfer effortlessly via Steam Cloud between the PC and the handheld PC, making it easy to continue on either device.

Red Dead Redemption 2 on Legion Go S
(Z1 Extreme, 32GB RAM, Steam OS)

I purchased a PS4 digital copy of Red Dead Redemption 2 for the PS5 on the PlayStation Store for £14.99, in anticipation of a potential native remastered version. If it eventually comes, hopefully it will be a free or £10 upgrade fee. But for it to happen, Rockstar needs to get their heads out of their asses, and finally give players what they’ve been asking for years! Whilst Grand Theft Auto is their golden egg, there are many, including myself, who prefer the Red Dead Redemption series. By not investing in or supporting upgrades, or even new single-player story content, they’ve missed out on a potential financial windfall, as both franchises can be equally successful.

I don’t usually create comparison articles, but the Red Dead Redemption 2 situation is frustrating and baffling. It took a while, but the original Red Dead Redemption eventually received a next-generation PS5 update; however, that may have happened because the PC finally got access to the game. So, perhaps it was a concerted effort by Rockstar to release on PC and, in the process of porting to the more powerful system, create upgrades for consoles too. With Red Dead Redemption 2 being the ultimate experience on PC, the desire to invest in console upgrades may be less appealing, but surely not impossible.

Grand Theft Auto V also got a next-gen upgrade on PS5; however, both the original Red Dead Redemption and Grand Theft Auto V launched on Xbox 360 and PS3, an entire generation before Red Dead Redemption 2’s PS4 and Xbox One launch. That doesn’t explain the lack of update, just that it’s technologically more advanced than the other two. But if a handheld PC can comfortably play RDR2, then so can the PS5 and Xbox Series X, and with a few setting tweaks, even the Nintendo Switch 2.

By Stephen Bradley-Waters

Jack of all trades, author and YouTube content creator, but also audiobook narrator, podcaster, and web designer. A connoisseur of all manner of geek-laden tasks and activities, from building and maintaining my gaming/production computers to collecting physical media and other cool and interesting products. I like to be proactive, so I'm never bored and constantly amuse myself.

error: Content is protected !!